ResultsFootball17 October 2026, 18:252 min read

Everton vs Chelsea prediction result: Under 3.5 goals wins

By The SharpTips Team

Vibrant aerial view of an empty football stadium pitch with colourful stands under a dramatic sky

Everton vs Chelsea finished 0-2, landing SharpTips’ pre-match Under 3.5 Goals selection at estimated odds of 1.50.

Everton and Chelsea’s Premier League meeting on Saturday 17 October finished 0-2, with two goals in total. That meant our pre-match Under 3.5 Goals prediction was a winner.

The selection was published at estimated odds of 1.50 with Medium confidence. Here is the reasoning behind it and how the final score matched the goals forecast.

Why the pre-match data favoured fewer goals

Before kick-off, Everton’s home defensive record was a key part of the case: they had conceded 0.7 goals per home league game. Chelsea had scored 1.3 goals per away game, a figure that suggested a measured scoring expectation rather than a clear case for a high total.

Everton’s recent results also pointed towards games with limited goals. Their 1-0 wins over Ipswich and Wolves, along with a 0-0 draw at Tottenham, offered evidence in support of staying below the 3.5-goal line. Those results did not guarantee the same pattern against Chelsea, but they helped shape the pre-match assessment.

Head-to-head evidence and reasons for caution

Four of the five supplied meetings between the sides had finished below 3.5 goals. That included Everton’s 3-0 home victory in March, which still landed under the threshold despite Everton scoring three times.

There was counterevidence, so the forecast was not treated as high confidence. Chelsea’s recent 5-1 and 6-3 wins showed their potential to contribute to a much higher total, while Everton had also recorded two recent 2-2 draws. With line-ups unpublished at the time, Medium confidence reflected both the support from Everton’s defensive figures and the uncertainty around the attacking evidence.

How the Under 3.5 Goals pick landed

The final score was Everton 0-2 Chelsea. With two goals in the match, the total finished below 3.5 and the selection won. The result aligned with the lower-scoring scenario identified in the preview, though the final score alone does not mean every similar forecast will succeed.

At estimated odds of 1.50, the pre-match analysis noted that the selection required roughly a 67% success rate to represent value. Everton’s defensive numbers suggested a modest edge over that threshold, rather than a decisive one. Betting involves risk, and not every pick wins; we report winning and losing selections alike.

More SharpTips predictions and our record

SharpTips subscribers can access the full prediction, all our picks, estimated odds and analysis. Our public track record includes every result, won or lost, and readers can also find three free predictions a day.